In Philadelphia, an ambitious effort to restructure the district has been proposed. The draft Blueprint for Reforming Philadelphia’s Public Schools, released in April 2012, sets two distinct goals: 1) Safe, high-performing schools district-wide; and 2) The elimination of a more than $200 million budget deficit by 2014. The plan proposes to address the deficit through renegotiated contracts, increased city funding, and operational efficiencies. Like the district’s reforms in the 2000s, the plan also emphasizes significant decentralization of district authority to external managers. But while the reforms a decade ago kept a solid majority of public schools under traditional district management, the current blueprint has the potential to impact every school. The proposed restructuring plan draws explicitly on the portfolio management design of school governance, which emphasizes market principles, expanded choice, and a sparse central management unit atop diverse, semi-autonomous networks of schools. Resources are redirected from under-enrolled or low-achieving schools toward higher-performing or improving schools through the increased use of school choice and closure policies. Based on RFA’s research on Philadelphia’s prior experience with governance changes and diverse providers, the experiences of other districts, and an examination of the relevant literature, key considerations include funding, management capacity, accountability, choice and equity, and politics. The purpose of this brief is to inform Philadelphia’s education community, policymakers, and stakeholders as these discussions move forward.
Related Publications
Publication
Examining the Impact, Implementation, and Cost Effectiveness of Completion Coaching in a Statewide College Promise Program
Dae Y. Kim, Karin Gegenheimer
Publication
Children’s Literacy Initiative’s Blueprint for Early Learning: Evaluation Report
Alyn Turner, Jill Pierce, Kendall LaParo
Publication
Virtual Approaches Hold Promise for Expanding Afterschool Art Programming
Wendy McClanahan, Tracey A. Hartmann
Publication
Small but Mighty: Lessons from Black Teachers’ Experiences in Allegheny County
Siettah Parks, Kevin Burgess, Leana Cabral, Mary Eddins, Alita Robinson
Publication
Allegheny County Teacher and Student Demographics: 2022-23 Update
Mary Eddins, David Lapp, Anna Shaw-Amoah
Publication
Top 5 Insights from RFA’s Community Research Partnership: Becoming a Community-Engaged Research Organization
Kate Callahan, Saxon Nelson
Publication
Exploring the Diversity and Supports for School District of Philadelphia English Learners as they Prepare to Transition to High School
David Bamat, Sean Vannata, Lindsey Liu, Molly Schlesinger, Alyn Turner
Publication
Setting the Stage: Practical Ideas for Implementing High-Quality Afterschool Arts Programs
Tracey A. Hartmann, Wendy McClanahan, Jill Pierce
Publication
Pennsylvania School Funding and School Staffing Disparities
David Lapp, Anna Shaw-Amoah
Publication
State Funding to Support Out-of-School Time Programming in Pennsylvania
Mark Duffy, Tracey A. Hartmann
Publication
“Worn & Weary” Black Teachers’ Storied Experiences and Recommendations around their Attrition and Retention in Philadelphia Schools
Leana Cabral, Lynnette Mawhinney, Jill Pierce, Carmina Hachenburg
Publication
Changing the Finish Line: Implications of new graduation requirements in the School District of Philadelphia
Sean Vannata, Anna Shaw-Amoah, Molly Pileggi, Molly Schlesinger, Theodore Wills, Roland Reyes, Alyn Turner